Joseph Pilates Never Taught Breathing Techniques!
Let’s Take Another Look at How We Teach Breathing In Pilates
Joseph Pilates states in his book, Return to Life Through Contrology, “…above all, learn how to breathe correctly.” (p. 13) And according to the Pilates Elder Mary Bowen, “His most important principle was to commit to total health for your whole life AND breathe.”
I start off with this not to argue that breathing is the most important Pilates principle. I like it just where it is – among the generally accepted six principles of Pilates. After all, trying to choose the one principle above all the rest feels like choosing a favorite child, though Alycea Ungaro makes a great case for ‘Control.‘
The point I want to make here is that breathing was very important to Joseph Pilates even though Mary Bowen states that he never taught a breathing technique. Indeed, nowhere will you find a demonstration of Pilates breathing on any of the films that show Joe or Clara teaching students!
So what’s with all our Youtube demonstrations of ‘Pilates Breathing?’ What’s withall the teacher training about Pilates breathing techniques? Where’s it all coming from?
Well, I have an idea! I think Joseph Pilates never taught any particular way of breathing on purpose! And now I think I know why a few of his students did develop and teach breathing techniques!
But first, let me share a few things I’ve learned about breathing from practicing and teaching Pilates for 4 decades. Pilates has been full of exciting discoveries for me and it’s one of the reasons I refer to Joseph Pilates as the ‘Einstein of fitness.’
Breathing and Beginners
First, there’s no breathing method that’s more important than just breathing! What I mean by this is that learning the form is quite enough for most beginners. Breathing patterns often just muddy the waters. At the same time I don’t avoid questions about it. Yes, Joseph Pilates preferred breathing thru the nose but never made this a rule (according to Mary Bowen), and yes, there are wonderful breathing patterns in each Pilates exercise that basically follow the natural mechanics of exhaling on exertion, but again, I don’t introduce breathing patterns until students have learned the form – first things first and for the beginner, having fun and not being overwhelmed is job #1!
One exception is ‘The 100.’ I’ve previously discussed adjusting the way we teach breathing in this exercise from the traditional 5/5 pattern (inhale for 5 arm pumps, exhale for 5 arm pumps) in favor of one that follows research confirming that we naturally take longer to exhale. So I teach a 4 pump inhale with a 6 pump exhale and it feels much better. Even here I’m cautious because, what the heck, the bottom line is just breathe! Breathe as much as you can particularly since we tend to hold our breath whenever we’re learning something, and that goes for anything, not just exercise. So just breathe!
I learned another interesting thing about breathing. Once the body learns the form of an exercise and becomes comfortable with it, breathing becomes full and relaxed. At this point Pilates breathing or ‘lateral breathing’ as many teachers refer to it, just happens naturally! Instead of complicated instruction, lateral breathing is simply a full breath without belly breathing. Nothing’s wrong with belly breathing. It’s simply not the most efficient or comfortable way to breathe when the core is strong.
Interestingly, after studying films of Joseph Pilates in action, and after talking to Mary Bowen who was taught by Joseph Pilates, I’m convinced that he purposely did not teach lateral breathing because he knew it was a natural consequence of a firm core, just as a firm core is a natural consequence of simply doing his exercises. Brilliantly simple – just do the exercises and breathe!
There are dozens of Youtube videos by well meaning and knowledgeable Pilates instructors explaining Pilates breathing. They are all interesting, but none of them are necessary for breathing correctly during Pilates. Plus, all of these videos are overwhelming for a beginner. For an experienced student, they’re fascinating, and herein lies the reason I believe some of his students developed breathing techniques. Let’s take a look at this. Incidentally, for one of the better video demonstrations of Pilates breathing click here. But if you’re a beginner just ignore it – ignore them all!
What Is Pilates Breathing
Although Joseph Pilates did not push any particular breathing technique, some of his students, most notably Ron Fletcher, introduced interesting methods such as ‘percussive breathing‘ (also known as ‘active breathing‘), ‘lateral breathing‘ and ‘bellows breathing’ – not bellows breathing as taught in yoga but rather as taught by my teacher Mary Bowen: inhaling as deeply as you can and exhaling forcefully like a bellows. But then again, Joe Pilates knew about hatha yoga so who knows? Mary Bowen explains that these breathing methods were developed by his students after Joe died, probably based on Joe’s emphasis on exhaling completely to insure a fuller inhale.
What about this? We know that Joe was an avid athlete and body builder from an early age. I believe he learned a breathing technique well-known in the body-building, deep-sea diving and high-altitude climbing worlds. I believe that this technique is the origin of Joe’s emphasis on the exhale and why some of his students went on to create a Pilates breathing method based on it.
Watch any Olympic weight lifting competition and you’ll see this technique in action. It is simply breathing forcefully and with some resistance on the exhale. What’s fascinating to me is that it really works in several ways: first, it creates a fuller inhale, second, it energizes in a way that enables one to exert more energy (for example, lift more weight) and finally, it increases the body’s absorption of oxygen. This last point is confirmed by research.
How To Do It
Simply exhale forcibly through pursed lips or over the tongue pressed gently against the upper palate. Don’t get caught up in the position of the lips or tongue, but rather simply force out your exhale and your lips or tongue will follow in whatever position is natural for you. Or simply observe experienced weight lifters at your local Y – they all do it! I believe Joe talked about this method to a couple of his advanced students who then went on to promote it after his death.
The Importance of Oxygen
Let’s look at just how important oxygen is. Many scientists consider oxygen the most important ingredient for the healthy functioning of the body. We get oxygen not just from breathing, but also from what we eat and drink and even to a lesser extent from absorption through our skin. But our major source of oxygen is breathing.
Increased breathing during exercise not only delivers more oxygen to our system. It also cleanses our lungs. The mild coughing and clearing of the throat that often occurs during exercise is the loosening and expectorating of the coating in our lungs which traps dust and particles that would otherwise hinder our absorption of oxygen.
Oxygen is our life-support. Without it we quickly die. Clean air is made up of 19-21% oxygen. Paleontologists who analyzed air bubbles trapped in fossilized amber discovered that oxygen levels were as high as 40% when the dinosaurs roamed the earth! The level of oxygen in our air today continues to decrease. Exercise and good nutrition are the best ways to insure that our body gets the oxygen it needs. Here are interesting facts about oxygen, and why it’s so important to our health:
- 80% of all our metabolic energy production is created by oxygen.
- Oxygen helps the body in its ability to rebuild itself and maintain a strong and healthy immune system.
- You can survive without food for about 40 days, without water for about 7 and without oxygen for only minutes.
- Foods which most deplete our bodies of oxygen are processed sugar, white flour, alcohol and caffeinated drinks.
- Our abilities to think, feel and act require oxygen-related energy production.
- Oxygen plays a vital role in blood circulation, assimilation of nutrients, digestion and the elimination of cellular and metabolic wastes.
- Eating junk food on a regular basis forces the body to use more oxygen in order to metabolize the added chemicals.
- Complex carbohydrates and raw fruits and vegetables are high in oxygen – as much as 50% of their weight which is why I encourage juicing. Get started with free juice recipes and juicer reviews at Juicing-Secrets.com. Get daily juicing tips on Facebook.
- The percentage of oxygen in fats is less than 15% while the percentage of oxygen in protein is between 20% and 40%.
- Excessive stress, such as working too much, traumatic events in your life, and prolonged depression or anxiety greatly depletes your body’s oxygen.
- Infection also depletes the body’s oxygen which is used to fight bacteria.
- Individuals with chronically acidic systems also use up oxygen reserves.
- The body absorbs more oxygen when it exercises.
- Oxygen heightens concentration, alertness and memory.
- 90% of our energy comes from oxygen, and only 10% from food and water.
- Oxygen speeds up the body’s recovery after physical exertiion.
- Oxygen provides a natural remedy for headaches, migraines, and hangovers.
- The steady decrease in our earth’s oxygen level is due to pollution, burning of fossil fuels and the destruction of the ozone layer.
- Every day we breathe 20,000 times.
- The brain, which makes up 2% of our total mass, requires 20% of the body’s oxygen.
- Research shows that our lung capacity decreases 5% with every decade of life.
- By mass, oxygen makes up 90% of the water molecule, and water makes up 65-75% of the human body.
- Cancer attacks every organ in our body except the heart because of its higher supply of oxygen.
So there you have it – my riff on breathing and Pilates. Do try the breathing technique – it works no matter what exercise you do. And if you found this article helpful, please like it and share it by clicking the icons at the top of this page.